About the show
Can you tell the difference between a secret and a lie? Four entertaining storytellers spin incredible tales about NYC’s secret past. All the stories are true except for one. If you can guess who’s the liar, you’ll go into the raffle to win a fantastic prize for you and your friends. Whether you love history, all things NYC, learning new stories to dazzle the people in your life, being part of a game show, or all of the above, this show is for you!

Upcoming shows
Tuesday, October 28, 2025 – TICKETS ON SALE NOW!
GHOST STORIES
All the stories in October’s show will be around the theme of NYC ghost stories to celebrate the spooky season! Join us for tricks, treats, and delightful scares to see if you can guess which ghost stories are documented and which one we completely made up. We’ll be back at the Hidden Jewel Box Theater, a secret theater hidden in Manhattan’s Port Authority Bus Terminal. Doors open at 7:30pm. Show starts at 8:00pm. NYC’s Secrets & Lies is created and hosted by Christa Avampato. Ashley Semrick and two other surprise guests will be featured in this show.

Past shows
September 23, 2025 – NATURE – Program Link
Storytellers: Christa Avampato. Ashley Semrick, Vicki Eastus, and Vicky Kuperman