About the show
Can you tell the difference between a secret and a lie? Four entertaining storytellers spin incredible tales about NYC’s secret past. All the stories are true except for one. If you can guess who’s the liar, you’ll go into the raffle to win a fantastic prize for you and your friends. Whether you love history, all things NYC, learning new stories to dazzle the people in your life, being part of a game show, or all of the above, this show is for you!

NYC’s Secrets and Lies: Prohibition
Wednesday, January 28, 2026
Doors open at 7:30pm
Show starts at 8:00pm

Purchase tickets:
https://lies.eventbrite.com/

All the stories in January’s show will be about Prohibition in NYC! Join us for tales of how the 1920s in NYC roared.

NYC’s Secrets & Lies is created and hosted by Christa Avampato. Bethany Fitch, Margo Mitchell, Melissa McGovern, and Taylor Moore will be featured in this show.

Location:
The Hidden Jewel Box Theater
625 8th Ave
New York, NY 10109

Location information:
Tucked away in a secret corner of the world’s busiest bus terminal, The Hidden Jewel Box Theater is a space like none other, a bohemian haven mixing decorative elements drawing from Rococo paintings, Victorian boudoirs, 1970s discotheques and Grimm fairy tales. Get your tickets now and become part of the secret, only at The Hidden Jewel Box Theater. Exact location and instructions for theater entrance emailed upon ticket purchase.

Partner with us!

Storyteller bios

Past shows